General Information &
Articles: All nations
Articles
Why
Dual Citizenship Can Be a Double-Edged
Sword by Marc J. Lane
Dual citizenship can't help but
water down patriotism.
Anti-American combatants
John Walker Lindh, the notorious "American Taliban," and Yaser Esam
Hamdi, a citizen of both the United States and Saudi Arabia, were
captured by U.S. troops in Afghanistan. But neither Mr. Lindh nor
Mr. Hamdi will be stripped of his U.S. citizenship, because in 1967
the U.S. Supreme Court ruled that citizenship is an inalienable
right that can only be lost if it's voluntarily
renounced.
The number of Americans who are also
citizens of other countries is soaring. And the growing prospect of
U.S. citizens serving in foreign, even antagonistic, armies and
governments, and foreign citizens serving in our own army and
government and voting in our elections, raises disturbing questions
about loyalty and national identity.
Dual citizenship is often an inadvertent
consequence of birth: A child of foreigners is born on U.S. soil or
a child of a U.S. citizen is born in another country. But,
increasingly, citizens of other countries become U.S. citizens by
choice. And many immigrants opt to remain nationals of their home
countries even as they gain U.S. citizenship, along with the
political rights and public benefits it affords them.
Immigration advocates don't fret about U.S.
citizens' ties to other countries. American identity, they argue,
isn't based on ethnicity or culture, but on the twin principles of
liberty and self-determination. And they insist that all of us
benefit when permanent residents of the U.S. pursue citizenship and
deepen their commitment to those American values.
Many proponents of dual citizenship seem to
buy into the logic. American Jews who want to move freely between
the U.S. and Israel, and even vote in both countries, are among
them.
It was a Jewish naturalized U.S. citizen
who moved to Israel and voted in an election there whose case
established the constitutional right to retain U.S. citizenship.
And since the Supreme Court so ruled, thousands of Americans have
served in foreign armies, most of them in the Israeli army, and
voted in foreign elections.
The globalization movement has also spurred
interest in dual citizenship. Beneficiaries of the North American
Free Trade Agreement and the European Union are happy to see
executives move without effort from one country to another and
harvest the rewards of multinational corporate trade.
Then there are foreign countries that seek
to benefit from the financial and political clout enjoyed by their
nationals abroad. They seem unstoppable in their encouragement of
expatriates to claim dual citizenship.
Mexico, the native land of more
foreign-born U.S. residents than any other, is the most blatant
example. The Mexican Nationality Law invites former Mexican
citizens who have been naturalized in the U.S.; or elsewhere, for
that matter; to have their Mexican citizenship restored without
losing their naturalized citizenship. The Mexican government treats
these new American citizens as "bi-nationals" and wants them to
vote in both the U.S. and Mexico, while Mexican politicians
campaign for their votes and their allegiance.
There's no question that dual citizenship
can make it easier to travel, work and own property in other
countries. But passports aren't credit cards to be collected and
used interchangeably whenever it's convenient.
Immigrants may sincerely profess their love
for both their native and adopted countries, but dual citizenship
can't help but water down patriotism. And shared national
loyalties, sooner or later, may come into conflict.
Congress shouldn't be winking and nodding
to new citizens who swear allegiance without meaning it. Instead,
it should empower the State Department to revoke one's citizenship
when his loyalty to another country can be proved. To do less
undermines our nationhood.
About the Author
Marc Lane is a business and tax attorney, a
Master Registered Financial Planner, a Registered Financial
Consultant, and a certified Investment Specialist. Marc is the
author of 30 books on business organization, taxation, and personal
finance. His newest book, "Advising Entrepreneurs: Dynamic
Strategies for Financial Growth" draws from his experience working
with those who have successfully built their businesses. Marc is an
Adjunct Professor of Law at Northwestern University and an Adjunct
Professor of Business at the University of Illinois. His practice
areas include Individual Taxation, Corporate Tax Planning, Business
Tax Planning, Estate Planning, Investments, Retirement
Planning,Elder Law, International Trade, Business Law, and Wills,
Trusts and Estates. Additional articles, case studies, and a free
email newsletter are available at www.marcjlane.com.
This article is provided courtesy of
http://www.citizen-test.wppts.com
.
You may freely reprint this article on your website or in your
newsletter provided this courtesy notice and the author name and
URL remain intact.
Could You Become a US
Citizen?
By
Jeffrey Hauser
Okay, I realize that most of
you reading this article already are citizens, but what if you
weren’t? My mother was born in Scotland and had to become a citizen
to stay and work in New Jersey, where we lived. But, back in the
sixties, the test was pretty intense. I remember spending hours
helping her memorize the presidents, amendments to the
constitution, and US history. The test has evolved over the years
and expect that everyone who was born in the US should be capable
of passing it. But why am I not so sure? Is it because when Jay
Leno does his “Jaywalking” segment filmed outside his studio and
asks questions like, “Who was the first President,” I cringe? It’s
because of the answers like, “Ben Franklin, Thomas Edison, or
Abraham Lincoln.” Yipes!
Fine, maybe he picked some slow
people that day. But how would you do answering sample questions
from the INS Citizenship test? Here’s you chance to prove me right
or wrong on how I think the average American would fare. Take your
time, good luck and please don’t’ cheat by looking at the answers
below. I’ve picked just 20 of a possible 100, at random.
- How many stripes are on the US
flag and what do they mean?
- Who was the first President of
the United States?
- Who is the current
Vice-President of the US?
- Who elects the President of
the US?
- For how long do we elect the
President?
- Who elects the
Congress?
- What is the supreme law of the
US?
- What is the Bill of
Rights?
- Who said, “Give me liberty or
give me death?”
- Name any 6 of the original 13
states.
- Who was the main writer of the
Declaration of Independence?
- Who was president during the
Civil War?
- Who selects the Supreme Court
Justices?
- What is the national anthem of
the US called and who wrote it?
- What type of government does
the US have?
- What month do we vote for the
President?
- What month is the President
inaugurated?
- How many times may a President
serve?
- How many states are there as
of 2007?
- Name any benefit of US
citizenship?
How did you do? Did you have to
peek at the answers? Shame on you! But, in all fairness, I doubt if
many would get all of these right. So here are the answers and I’ll
discuss a few at the bottom.
- There are 13 stripes, each
representing an original state.
- George Washington was the
first President.
- Richard B. Cheney is the
current Vice-President in 2007.
- The electoral college actually
elects the President.
- The President serves for 4
years in a term.
- Congress is elected directly
by the people.
- The Constitution is the
supreme law of the US.
- The first 13 amendments to the
Constitution are called the Bill of Rights.
- Patrick Henry said, “Give me
liberty of give me death.”
- The original states are:
Connecticut, New Hampshire, New York, New Jersey, Massachusetts,
Pennsylvania, Delaware, Virginia, North Carolina, South Carolina,
Georgia, Rhode Island, and Maryland.
- Thomas Jefferson was the main
writer of the Declaration of Independence.
- Abraham Lincoln was President
during the Civil War.
- The President of the US
selects Supreme Court Justices.
- The US national anthem is the
“Star-Spangled Banner” by Frances Scott Key.
- The United States operates
under a Democracy.
- We vote for the President in
November.
- The President takes the oath
of office in January.
- The President may only serve
2, 4-year terms of office.
- Currently, in 2007, we have 50
states, including the District of Columbia.
- A Benefit of citizenship? This
is for you to decide.
The last question could be
answered by using the amendments of the Bill of Rights. Here are
just a few, beginning with the very first one: You have the right
of freedom of speech, press, religion, peaceable assembly, and
requesting change of government. You have the right to bear arms
(the right to have weapons or own a gun, though subject to certain
regulations). A person may not be tried twice for the same crime
and does not have to testify against him/herself. You have the
right to trial by jury in most cases. In addition, here are some
others: You are allowed to vote and elect your representatives, you
are protected by the US military and local police, you are subject
to everything written into the Constitution and therefore can live
with more freedom than in almost any other country.
So, once again, how did you do?
The INS is considering going to multiple choices in 2008, but with
some tougher questions. Such as, “name your two state Senators,
what is our economic system called, and what was the primary
purpose of the Declaration of Independence?” But, aside from those,
you should have known every one of the above 20 questions. Most
children are taught the answers by high school. If you had trouble
with a few, then you’re probably average. More than 10, then you
should hit the books. More than 15? How long have you lived here?
If you got them all wrong? De donde eres, por favor?
Jeffrey Hauser was a sales
consultant for the Bell System Yellow Pages for nearly 25 years. He
graduated from Pratt Institute with a BFA in Advertising and has a
Master's Degree in teaching. He had his own advertising agency in
Scottsdale, Arizona and ran a consulting and design firm, ABC
Advertising. He has authored 6 books and a novel, "Pursuit of the
Phoenix." His latest book is, "Inside the Yellow Pages" which can
be seen at his website, http://www.poweradbook.com
Currently, he is the Marketing
Director for http://www.thenurseschoice.com
a Health Information and Doctor
Referral site.
Article Source:
http://EzineArticles.com/?expert=Jeffrey_Hauser
|